E-learning: better than face-to-face?
AUGUST 23, 2013
blended learning > e-learning > face-to-face learning! recently discovered a three year old research report from the Department of Education in the United States. meta-analysis, encompassing studies covering a 12 year period from 1996 to 2008, it compares the effectiveness of e-learning and blended learning to face-to-face instruction. Advocates of e-learning have argued for some time that it is at least as good as face-to-face methods, but this research appears to provide substantial supporting evidence. Report here
Learning evaluation solutions
SEPTEMBER 16, 2011
Keen readers of this blog may have noticed a shift of emphasis in recent posts. I've apparently become much more interested in the evaluation of learning and development. In fact, this has been a career-long interest, and has always formed a part of my professional work. However, I have let the cat out of the bag with my latest LinkedIn update - "planning a new venture!"
JANUARY 23, 2012
I once attempted a joke about e-learning, following Don Morrison’s suggestion that a measure of an industry, profession or sector’s maturity is the emergence of jokes about it. In that spirit, the prospects for learning evaluation are discouraging. The thing is, it’s not even true. The advent of digital technology has made learning evaluation more affordable, efficient and effective.
New Brandon Hall Group report forecasts major shift in 2016 online learning trends
Companies are increasingly dissatisfied with online learning tools, prompting many to reinvest in technology that supports a modern training approach. Download the report from Brandon Hall Group to see how new investments are bringing real business results.
The State of Learning Evaluation in Scotland
MARCH 13, 2013
My learning evaluation business, Airthrey Ltd , is conducting research into the State of Learning Evaluation in Scotland. Our aim is to find out who’s evaluating learning and development in Scotland, who’s doing it well, and what it is that makes them successful. We believe this will provide a useful benchmark for studies of learning evaluation in other countries. Survey: www.survey.bris.ac.uk/stirling/learnevalu
More about MOODLE
JULY 31, 2010
Thanks to those who replied to my previous blog post. My quest to improve my organisation's MOODLE implementation goes on. The next phase of development addresses three themes: overall look-and-feel, to make the site more user-friendly and give it more visual appeal; developing micro-sites within the site to support different communities of practice; and (three weeks on) still working on the course content development capability. We've compared a lot of alternative tools, and decided against Sana EasyGenerator (sorry, Christiaan), as well as proprietary tools like Lectora and ToolBook.
Forget learning styles
JULY 30, 2012
This morning I responded to a LinkedIn discussion on learning styles, questioning the interest. In my blog post of 4 May I noted that “Honey and Mumford’s learning styles theory, along with the competing theory of Colin Rose, has been widely discredited, at least in academic circles”, and cited this handy compendium of evidence and comment debunking the learning styles myth. No more than that.
JULY 14, 2011
A client asked me today about approaches to evaluation, and this got me thinking about how advocates of different approaches get very dogmatic about what works and what doesn’t work. Kaliym Islam, in Developing and Measuring Training the Six Sigma Way , says “none of the four levels in the Kirkpatrick model capture business feedback or business reaction to the training product”.
Adventures in Moodle
JULY 3, 2011
Picking up from some of my previous blog posts, it’s now over a year since my organisation established an online learning environment, based on a Moodle platform. It’s been an interesting journey. Initially I expected to get three things: 1. learner management system , enabling us to store information about learners and generate reports. 2. And we don’t have the third thing.
Are you my friend?
MAY 1, 2011
Driving to work the other day, I heard an item on Radio Scotland about how many online “friends” we can realistically maintain. I’m not sure how this became a topical item for commuter news, as I have investigated further and discovered Robin Dunbar identified the number – it’s 150 – way back in 2008. See this New Scientist link.)
Learning from mistakes
JANUARY 26, 2011
I subscribe to training zone and find some of their articles useful, amid a sea of thinly-disguised sales promotions. recent example of the useful stuff is the ‘the top 10 bad people managers’ by blogger Simon Kenny, who lists some great examples of mistaken behaviour by managers. You need to register for training zone to view his blog.) We need help.
JULY 25, 2011
I'm looking for examples of learning evaluation in practice - both good and bad. I'd welcome anything from a bank of case studies to any small anecdote anyone is willing to share. And I'm interested in any context of learning and development implementation. Can anyone help? Please use the comments option, below, to post links, or email me via the learnforever website. Thanks
APRIL 29, 2013
In the current issue of Management Today , Nigel Nicholson offers “A New View of Leadership”. Some of what he describes is not new – he offers a triangular model of seeing (vision), being (identity), and doing (action), which may be considered an attempt to bring together visionary, authentic, and action-based approaches to leadership. We are all (potential) leaders, we are all Spartacus.
Education and training spend in the UK
NOVEMBER 13, 2012
In the foreword to Brinkerhoff and Apking’s High Impact Training (2001), Professor Dale M Brethower identified the total US spend on education, “from kindergarten through graduate school” at $230 billion, and estimated that employers pass on to consumers at least $300 billion in spend on training and development. Current UK public expenditure on education is around the £90 billion mark.
Case study, part one
FEBRUARY 4, 2012
In the 1990s, Pitman Publishing Limited, wholly owned by Pearson plc, was the biggest business book publisher in the UK – by far. Its nearest rival, Kogan Page, was about one third of its size. Pitman wanted to grow, but felt it had exhausted the possibilities for organic growth, and so it turned to acquisitions. This added capability in management training videos, in DVD format.
Sharing learning across the third sector
MAY 13, 2014
Today, I am delighted to be launching the Academy – sharing learning across the third sector. This new initiative has been a long time coming: since I first discussed the concept with David Elder nearly three years ago, the model has changed twice, funding partners have come and gone, but at last, today, the company I incorporated last year finally gets off the ground. Let me know what you think
Storyboarding for eLearning
Storyboarding is a very important step for creating eLearning courses. But don’t you feel it’s a waste of time to start creating the courses from scratch and copy-paste text and other objects from the storyboard to the eLearning tool for course development.
JANUARY 30, 2010
I’m in the middle of a major new MOODLE implementation. For those who don’t know, MOODLE is an open source virtual learning environment; the initials stand for Modular Object-Oriented Dynamic Learning Environment, although enthusiasts (and there seem to be plenty of them) also use “moodle” as a verb. More information at [link]. We haven’t yet got to significant content development.
Learning Evaluation Network
JANUARY 20, 2014
When is a social network not a social network? This issue was raised in the testing phase of the Learning Evaluation Network (LEN), just launched on the Ning platform. Ning describes all the networks it supports as “social networks” but this conveys all sorts of assumptions, largely based on the most widely-recognised Facebook model. Evaluation of learning and development is pretty niche.
Explaining Total Value Add
SEPTEMBER 17, 2013
One or two people who have read the e-book I published last year with Alasdair Rutherford – Total Value Add, a new approach to evaluating learning and development – have asked for more information about how Total Value Add works. Total Value Add includes two related ideas. Let’s take the first idea first. That’s one example. More information can be found at www.airthrey.com
a new chapter
DECEMBER 8, 2014
I''m in the process of winding up two of my recent ventures. I''ve announced on LinkedIn and Twitter that the Academy for Shared Learning, the social enterprise I have been developing for the past two years and that finally launched earlier this year, has been voluntarily wound up by its members. Sadly, the Academy proved unable to generate the levels of interest needed to sustain it. So what''s new? I''m joining Sense Scotland as its new Head of Organisational Development. It''s a big challenge, but one I am really looking forward to meeting. More to follow, I''m sure
Evaluating Training - Capturing the Benefits Aspects of ROI
Training evaluation is necessary and, in many ways, critical to the success of a business. But because short term priorities always seem to take precedence, it is typically something we plan to do better in the next course, or maybe next month, or even next year. After all, we’ve managed pretty well up to now, so surely another year can’t hurt!
A book a year
MAY 2, 2013
I’ve been doing a lot more writing in the six years since I launched this blog. After an eight year gap from my first book to my second, I’ve had three books published in the last four years (see sidebar links), and I’m planning to step up that rate. Not that this is the season for resolutions, but I’ve decided to aim to write and publish one new book every year.
Reason overcome by emotions
APRIL 14, 2013
If you’re not interested in football, you could be forgiven for wondering what all the fuss was about recently-appointed Sunderland coach Paolo di Canio, and revelationsof his fascist sympathies. In a nutshell, many people involved with Sunderland Football Club would prefer they did not employ someone of such an extreme political persuasion. suspect there are many other examples.
MARCH 8, 2013
A few years ago, I wrote about Roberto Moretti's Practice Made Perfec t system, as an approach to helping people learn skills. I've recently found a useful follow-up in an unlikely source. European coaches have introduced a lot of new thinking and techniques to British football, and perhaps none more so than the two great Portuguese coaches Jose Mourinho and Andreas Villas-Boas.
The Shared Academy
FEBRUARY 19, 2013
When I wrote the corporate universities chapter for CIPD’s Learning and Development subscription manual (published 2007, but no longer available), I wrote: “ That is not to say that the corporate university (CU) is the sole preserve of the large corporation. In the six years since I wrote that, through a global recession, the argument has become more compelling.
Seven Simple Secrets to Off-the-Shelf Course Success
Off-the-shelf elearning is applicable for a wide audience, but it won’t address your organization’s unique situations or distinctive content. So are these courses all that helpful? For sure! Read on for 7 secrets to make off-the-self learning your own.
Signed copy of the Learnforever Book
AUGUST 4, 2014
I''m offering all readers and followers of this blog the chance to buy a copy of the Learnforever Book, direct from the author, at a reduced price and with extra benefits. For just £12 sterling, you can have a copy of The Learnforever Book, signed by the author, with the personalised inscription of your choice, posted to any address anywhere in the world. Published in December 2013, The Learnforever Book is a collection of posts and comments from this blog, between 2007 and 2013, edited and with a new introduction and index.
Happy New Year!
JANUARY 17, 2013
Happy New Year to all my clients, followers and readers. hope 2013 brings everything you want and need. My thanks are due to Bob Little for my inclusion in his list of 2012 " e- learning movers and shakers ". My book, Delivering E-Learning is still available
Growing faster than Facebook
JANUARY 17, 2013
Was 2012 the Year of the MOOC? That’s the title of an article from the New York Times in November , but if that’s the case, what are we going to call 2013? And is MOOC pioneer Andrew Ng right that it’s “growing faster than Facebook”? MOOC stands for Massive Open Online Courses, which already seem like such an obvious development one wonders why they haven’t been around for much longer.
DECEMBER 20, 2012
As it’s that time of the year again, I thought I’d lighten the mood with a wee quiz. It’s more fun if you don’t Google the answers! And I’ll post them in the comments section in a day or two. No prizes, just the deep satisfaction of being a know-all. 1. What is the usual colour of a flight recorder black box? 2. How long did the Hundred Years War last? 3. What country makes Panama hats? 4.
Move Beyond Learning to Applying: A Modern Management Development Program
A better way to develop front-line managers !It’s well documented that people leave managers – not companies. Download this guide to learn how to shift the perspective from event to journey and how to take learners through Proficiency Journeys to get results.
Health & Safety Culture
DECEMBER 18, 2012
As we approach the end of 2012, I'm reflecting on a year when human resource issues were frequently to the fore. Back in January, the government jumped on the bandwagon of complaining about health and safety "red tape". David Cameron promised he was "waging war against the excessive health and safety culture that has become an albatross around the neck of British businesses". How quickly we forget!
Against the herd
DECEMBER 13, 2012
When I worked for Pearson plc in the 1990s, I was part of a newly-created business, Financial Times Management, specialising in management education. When that business was just two years old, a decision was taken no rebrand it as FT Knowledge. Haven't we just had a restyling? Are the benefits of the latest change a worthwhile use of CIPD member subscriptions?
Another evaluation update
DECEMBER 4, 2012
In June, I wrote about progress in what was then a brand new action development programme. That was the first cohort, since completed, of LEAD, which stands for Learning Evaluation Action Development, and is Airthrey Ltd’s flagship programme. LEAD aims to support and equip those responsible for learning evaluation to conduct their own evaluation project (something real, not a simulation).
NOVEMBER 29, 2012
The latest issue of People Management quotes Mike Morrison ( @RapidBI on Twitter) "at the Olympic Games, many, many people got a lot out of volunteering. This should be explored as a business strategy". This will come as no surprise to many in the 'Big Society', from the public and third sectors, where volunteering as a means of delivering public services is increasingly a way of life.
5 Unknown Ways You're Wasting Your Training Budget
In the US alone, companies spend over $70 billion on corporate training and about $1000 on individual employees according to Bersin by Deloitte. When it comes to training budgets, leaders struggle to pinpoint what impact (if any) their training programs are having. So what's the result? Companies end up wasting millions of dollars each year on ineffective training practices.
How learning adds value
NOVEMBER 28, 2012
I’m developing a model showing the various ways learning adds value in an organisation, and so far I’ve identified four clusters of different ways. The classic learning paradigm This is the process flow from: acquisition of knowledge/skills/behaviours; to performance improvement; to business results. This is the main sort of value we expect learning to add. Does it make sense?
NOVEMBER 19, 2012
We live in a world of big data. As the cliché has it, the Internet changes everything, and it has certainly transformed our access to reams of data and valuable analysis of it. spent the recent US Presidential election campaign following the blogging exploitsof Nate Silver , erstwhile poker player and baseball analyst. You had people saying 'you can't quantify people's feelings through numbers!'
An appeal for crowdfunding
NOVEMBER 16, 2012
I’m looking for contributions to fund a research project on evaluation of learning and development. Although focused on Scotland, the project should have clear implications for the wider world. discovered crowdfunding when a friend’s son, a photographer, was involved with a group of people in making a short film, and they used it to raise all the funding they needed.
Success Case Method
NOVEMBER 7, 2012
Working on evaluation of learning and development, one of the things that amazes me is how little known, and how little used, is the Success Case Method. It shouldn’t really amaze me that much, as I only discovered it myself after writing my last book, 101 Learning and Development Tools , which means it doesn’t feature in the book, despite 21 of the tools being about evaluation. Contribute here.
Workbook: Gamification and Your Enterprise Learning Strategy
This workbook is a response to your need to understand how to strategically incorporate gamification into your learning strategy, in order to drive real business results. It’s designed to be printed, written in and used as a guide.
NOVEMBER 5, 2012
I feel as though I've always known that a story should have a beginning, a middle and an end. Now I learn, from the Harvard Business Review , that this is an Aristotelian model. But I digress.) I wholeheartedly endorse the main point of the Harvard link, that effective presentations are rather like story-telling. Indeed there are broader lessons for leadership and influencing.
The ubiquity of leadership
OCTOBER 16, 2012
When people ask me the difference between leadership and management, I ask them to consider the difference between management and governance. Not that I’m equating governance with leadership, but I think this is a good place to start. Management is essentially about administration, while governance is about oversight of an organisation’s work. Surely this is tautology? Non-operational management?