Measuring Project Success: Thoughts for the Training Professional.
Dashe & Thomson
APRIL 23, 2011
Social Learning Blog Training and Performance Improvement in the Real World Home About Bios Subscribe to RSS Measuring Project Success: Thoughts for the Training Professional by Jim on April 24, 2011 in Project Management/Project Delivery When we think of the concept of “success,” it often seems relatively straightforward. Looking back on your day, for instance, it’s generally an easy thing to sum up whether it was successful or not. Did your presentation go well to that big prospective client, or did your car break down on the way to work? Were you able to get the gym as you had hoped, or did your boss need you to work late on someone else’s project? Easily definable items such as these, measured against a finite number of other events, allow for relatively rapid analysis. Yet, when one extends the number of competing factors a bit, measurement becomes increasingly difficult. Just as it is generally easy enough to determine if your day went well, deciding if you had a good year can be a bit harder. For one thing, how do you weigh competing factors against each other when there are so many more to choose from? Is financial success the most important item, or personal fulfillment, or a host of other things that happen over the course of a large timeframe? These questions are the same ones that face project managers every day, as they struggle with the ever-present dilemma of demonstrating success to project stakeholders. The first real issue is that few projects have just one stakeholder, and each stakeholder may have their own definition of success. As noted by William R. Duncan in Defining and Measuring Project Success : “The health and safety officer wants no injuries. The manufacturing manager wants a product that is easy to build. The ISO 9000 compliance team cries “success” if the documentation is complete. The VP of Marketing will be delighted if you get to market before your competition.” This can be especially true in the training field, where the training department’s ideas of success can be vastly different from a harried team manager who wants to minimize lost productivity due to excessive training. So, how can a poor project manager navigate these dangerous waters? Preparation, preparation, preparation. And by that I mean, documentation, documentation, documentation. It is imperative that your client recognizes, in writing, that a, b, and c factors constitute success, while factor d is not important and should not be used. Since you may have only one immediate contact, often within the training department, it’s a good idea to dig deeper. Ask for sign-off on the success factors from all the key people, whether you’ll meet them or not (this helps your immediate contact, too, which is pretty handy). Furthermore, note the assumptions on which these success factors are based. If your client wants you to get an elearning module built based on storyboards developed in-house, make sure it’s clear that your work is entirely dependent on their work. And make sure it is documented and clearly understood how to escalate those issues up the chain of command, if you have to. Finally, don’t oversimplify when writing out the success factors, but don’t over-measure, either. For example, writing “All milestones will be completed on time” as a success factor doesn’t give enough leeway that you may need in the normal course of events. William Duncan suggests using a structured format to overcome oversimplication. His example: Stock intro: “one key success measure for this project is to have…” Measurable item: ‘the completion date of every major milestone” Comparison statement: “within” Some number: “one week of the baseline schedule date” This example provides specificity and flexibility, all at the same time. The result is a measurement that is easy to understand, and leaves wiggle-room where appropriate. Ultimately, these ideas only scratch the surface of what is important in demonstrating success to your client. The ultimate truth is that success can only come from communication, so talk with your client. Dig deep. And let me know your thoughts! Blog this! Bookmark on Delicious Digg this post Recommend on Facebook Buzz it up Share on Linkedin share via Reddit Share with Stumblers Tweet about it Subscribe to the comments on this post Print for later Bookmark in Browser Tell a friend Tags: budgeting , customer service , elearning , feedback , project management , stakeholder About Jim Im a Project Manager for Dashe & Thomson, focused on getting the best results for clients whether big (Fortune 500) or small (Fortune 500,000). My goal is to make sure that no matter the size of the project, each company that comes to us gets immediate, attentive, personal service. When Im not busy helping to change the face of corporate learning, I like to train with the Dashe & Thomson company bike team, travel and read. View all posts by Jim → ← Embracing Innovation in Learning Three Reasons Why Corporate Training Departments Could Become Extinct → Download Free Whitepaper The Top 10 Pitfalls of End User Training – and How to Avoid Them Given the current state of the economy, businesses large and small are looking for ways to improve productivity while maintaining quality. Download the whitepaper » Blog this! Bookmark on Delicious Digg this post Recommend on Facebook Buzz it up Share on Linkedin share via Reddit Share with Stumblers Tweet about it Subscribe to the comments on this post Print for later Bookmark in Browser Tell a friend 2 Responses to “Measuring Project Success: Thoughts for the Training Professional Jeff Colosimo May 3, 2011 at 10:03 pm # Thanks for including a blog post on this topic. As a business owner, I often feel overwhelmed by the number of tasks in front of me. They all seem like a priority and they can be difficult to delegate. Having documentation readily available is very handy for maneuvering from task to the next. I try to minimize the time spent a variety of projects whenever I can, which is why social learning is handy – it cuts down on time and money. Thanks again for this strategy. It’s very insightful. Jim May 4, 2011 at 6:42 pm # Glad you found the post helpful, Jeff! Properly documenting expectations, responsibilities, and success factors can be one of the most vital aspects of successful project management, but it’s so often overlooked or treated as merely an exercise. Personally, I’m still working on every new project to fine tune the proper “documentation ratio. Leave a Reply Click here to cancel reply. Search the blog Popular Latest Comments Tags Web-Based, Instructor-Led, EPSS? Train Your Client On Training January 31, 2011 Leveraging the Law of the Few to Manage Change in the Workplace February 21, 2011 Analyzing the ROI of Social Media in Training May 3, 2011 Why eLearning Development Ratios Can be Hazardous to Your Career November 15, 2010 eLearning Review: A Module for the National Security Arena October 15, 2010 Virtual Boot-Camp: Games and Learning with the U.S. Military May 19, 2011 Give User Adoption the Respect it Deserves May 17, 2011 How Social Networks Can Harness the Power of Weak Ties May 11, 2011 Addressing On-Demand Learning and Performance Needs #LCBQ May 9, 2011 Why Companies Should Spend More on Social Learning May 5, 2011 Gregg Sean: Nice review of the topic , I was seeking to see wh. Rob Mueller: Great post on using games as a training device. Pe. Jim: Glad you enjoyed the post, Liam! It is amazing ho. Liam McCoy: Thanks for this. Ive been looking for some ammo t. Jim: Glad you found the post helpful, Jeff! Properly d. blended learning budgeting Classroom Learning classroom training customer service Donald Kirkpatrick elearning ERP Training Facebook Facilitation feedback ILT Informal Learning innovation instructional design instructor-led training interactive learning Jane Bozarth JIT learning Kanye West LinkedIn LMS marketing MNISPI mobile learning peer-to-peer learning performance support project management Robert Brinkerhoff sales social learning social learning theory social media subject matter experts Success Case Method surveys synchronous system implementation training temporary staffing Training Development Twitter video web-based training Wikis youtube Email Alerts Follow Us! Tweets Follow @dashethomson on Twitter Download Free Whitepaper The Top 10 Pitfalls of End User Training – and How to Avoid Them Given the current state of the economy, businesses large and small are looking for ways to improve productivity while maintaining quality. Download the whitepaper » Blog this! Bookmark on Delicious Digg this post Recommend on Facebook Buzz it up Share on Linkedin share via Reddit Share with Stumblers Tweet about it Subscribe to the comments on this post Print for later Bookmark in Browser Tell a friend Other Learning Blogs Andrew McAfee’s Blog The Rapid eLearning Blog Big Dog, Little Dog Bozarthzone Discovery Through eLearning E-learning Curve Blog eLearning Roadtrip The Learning Generalist ID and Other Reflections The eLearning Coach Harold Jarche: Life in Perpetual Beta Weejee Learning Making Change: Ideas for Lively eLearning Corporate eLearning Strategies and Development eLearning Technology The Learning Circuits Blog Cammy Bean’s Learning Visions Kapp Notes Internet Time Blog Will at Work Learning eLearning Learning Dave’s Whiteboard Communication Nation Categories blended learning (7) budgeting (2) Classroom Learning (8) customer service (3) Development Tools (4) EHR Training (1) eLearning (13) ERP Training (2) Facilitation (2) feedback (2) Gaming Theory (2) Informal Learning (15) Innovation (1) Instructional Design (10) Leadership (1) LMS (Learning Management System) (3) marketing (2) mobile learning (3) Organizational Change Management (2) performance support (8) Project Management/Project Delivery (6) Reviews (2) sales (3) social learning (27) Social Media (1) subject matter experts (3) system implementation training (3) Temporary staffing (1) Training Development (9) user adoption (1) Video (5) Wikis (3) Archives May 2011 (6) April 2011 (12) March 2011 (13) February 2011 (7) January 2011 (9) December 2010 (7) November 2010 (2) October 2010 (1) September 2010 (1) February 2010 (1) © 2011 Social Learning Blog. All Rights Reserved. Visit us at dashe.com