Alternative to the Kirkpatrick Model of Training Evaluation

LearnDash

If you have been in the elearning (or training) industry for any amount of time, then you are most likely aware of the Kirkpatrick model of learning evaluation. One could write an entire book on the Kirkpatrick model and the different levels, but I am not going to get into too much detail. On nearly every consulting project I have worked on, the Kirkpatrick model has been what we have used to gather and report data to the client.

Kirkpatrick Revisited | Social Learning Blog

Dashe & Thomson

Social Learning Blog Training and Performance Improvement in the Real World Home About Bios Subscribe to RSS Kirkpatrick Revisited by Barbara on April 18, 2011 in Instructional Design After I finished my post a few weeks ago on Reevaluating Evaluation , I found out that Donald Kirkpatrick , the granddaddy of the Four Levels of Evaluation, was taking a farewell tour before his retirement and would be presenting a workshop at the American Society of Training and Development (ASTD) in Minneapolis.

Insiders

Sign Up for our Newsletter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

50 Years of the Kirkpatrick Model

Upside Learning

In the fifty years since, his thoughts (Reaction, Learning, Behavior, and Results) have gone on to evolve into the legendary Kirkpatrick’s Four Level Evaluation Model and become the basis on which learning & development departments can show the value of training to the business. In November 1959, Donald Kirkpatrick published a series of seminal articles on training evaluation in the ‘Journal of the ASTD’.

Is It Time To Kill the Kirkpatrick Model?

Trivantis

The Kirkpatrick Model for training evaluation is kind of like Old Faithful. It’s been around since the 1950s and provides an easy to understand framework for evaluating your training program. Here is the model as described by the Kirkpatrick Partners: But is the Kirkpatrick Model still valid? However, not everyone hates the Kirkpatrick Model. To Kirkpatrick or not to Kirkpatrick is not a new controversy.

Re-evaluating Evaluation | Social Learning Blog

Dashe & Thomson

Social Learning Blog Training and Performance Improvement in the Real World Home About Bios Subscribe to RSS Re-evaluating Evaluation by Barbara on March 16, 2011 in Project Management/Project Delivery For years, I have dutifully included a description of Kirkpatrick’s Four Levels of Learning Evaluation in every proposal for every company I have worked with. And as time has gone by, I have started to wonder about the validity of Kirkpatrick in today’s world.

Podcast 32: Building a Customer Education Business Case – With Bill Cushard of Learndot

Talented Learning

For example, I worked on elearning projects for customers at Accenture. So now, I don’t have to worry about Kirkpatrick’s 4 levels of employee training evaluation. ” That’s important when you’re optimizing a mature customer training program.

Accelerated Learning: Where Does It Fit In? | Social Learning Blog

Dashe & Thomson

I started thinking about this during a program on Accelerated Learning at the Minnesota Chapter of the International Society of Performance Improvement (MNISPI). Then I remembered a series of highly successful training programs designed to address the three learning styles at the Minneapolis Institute of Arts. The audience for the training programs was junior high school students, and the purpose was to learn about works of art in the museum’s collection.

Learning Design: The Great, The Good and The Good Enough

Wonderful Brain

The best and greatest courseware, the most inventive and exciting depends on a designer who can sculpt content into a story, then work with an interactive and/or graphic designer to sharpen the user experience across multiple platforms finally passing the work to a developer to program—as designed—for implementation. An entire industry has been built around PowerPoint (by example) as the foundation for programs like Articulate. This could be a story about buggy whips.

The Lonely eLearner: Creating Social Learning Anchors | Social.

Dashe & Thomson

Social Learning Blog Training and Performance Improvement in the Real World Home About Bios Subscribe to RSS The Lonely eLearner: Creating Social Learning Anchors by Andrea on March 9, 2011 in LMS (Learning Management System) , blended learning , eLearning , feedback , social learning The other day, I ran across Clive Shepherd’s recent blog post The New Social Learning – a review and I was struck by an observation he made there.

Social 130

Make Learning An Experience. Blend It! | Social Learning Blog

Dashe & Thomson

by Michael on March 7, 2011 in blended learning If you still believe that “classroom learning is the best learning” for your training and learning programs, I have some news for you. Allow them to discover information in bite-sized portions through self-directed activities such as eLearning, and then follow-up with a workshop, discussion group, open lab, or other opportunity to apply the new information.

ROI and Metrics in eLearning

Tony Karrer

I'm working on an article around the use of ROI and metrics in eLearning. Kirkpatrick's Level 3: Improving the Evaluation of E-Learning Level 3 evaluations measure whether the there was an actual transfer of learning to the actual work setting. To ensure adequate funding and organization-wide commitment to your training program, you must be equally committed to Online Course Development: What Does It Cost?

Free learning & development webinars for October 2021

Limestone Learning

PT: Community Member Showcase Join TLDCast’s crowdcast as they feature Gwen Navarrete Klapperich, Chief Learning Consultant of Klapperich International Training Associates (KITA) LLC. You’ll explore WCAG/508/AODA guidelines and how they apply to elearning courses.

Free 95

Learning and Development Glossary

Petra Mayer

From Cloud to Scorm, to Authoring tool to Microlearning – eLearning has become a full-fledged industry. There are a number of factors that embody eLearning, helping it become a driver for personal and professional advancement. CBT describes the on-demand elements of eLearning.

Free L&D webinars for January 2021

Limestone Learning

Join Olu Burrell, CEO of Olu Burrell Consulting, for a session where you’ll: Learn the Three Value Proposition , a framework for aligning your values to your career path no matter the conditions. How do we design training and learning programs that goes beyond following rules and knowledge?

Free 99

Free L&D webinars for January 2020

Limestone Learning

Recommend effective coaching program leaders. Wednesday, January 8, 2020, 9AM – 10AM PT: Best Practices for Implementing Gamification in Your Training Programs Gamification is an important and powerful strategy for influencing and motivating people.

Commonly Used Training Evaluations Models: A Discussion with Dr. Will Thalheimer

Convergence Training

And if you’d like to read other discussions we’ve had with Will, click these links to learn more about spaced practice , the effectiveness of elearning , smile sheets, and learning myths v. Here’s some research I did with the eLearning Guild just last year. But this research study is available at the eLearning Guild. And I do this a lot in my consulting work. Four Common Learning Evaluation Models–Kirkpatrick, Kaufman, Philips & Brinkerhoff.

Instructional Design: The Process – 1

Origin Learning

There have been all types of blend in learning, using all possible avenues from brick-and-mortar classrooms, virtual classrooms, eLearning, digital tutorials, videos, to xAPI tracking all forms of social or informal learning. Instructional Design (ID) is a process or systematic approach to developing the various learning courses or programs. Use the Ruth Clark’s media principles of design for effective eLearning.

Free learning & development webinars for April 2021

Limestone Learning

PT: Rethinking the Way You Author Elearning Whether in a large enterprise or a team of one, elearning authors today are expected to deliver effective learning outcomes using minimal resources, rapid turn-around time and a razor-thin budget.

Free 75

Free L&D webinars for May 2020

Limestone Learning

In this webinar, with Jim Kirkpatrick, Ph.D., Join Juan Moran, Solutions Consultant at NovoEd, for a demo to learn how NovoEd’s collaborative learning platform enables global enterprises to transform in-person workshops into highly engaging digital learning experiences.

Free 60

Measuring Learning Effectiveness: Beyond Training Happy Sheets & Memory Recall

Learning Cafe

Despite Learning measurement frameworks like Kirkpatrick and Philips ROI that have been around for so many years, defining meaningful measures still continues to be a big challenge for L&D. How can L&D learn what the business desires or intends from learning programs? Will Thalheimer, PhD, is a consultant and research translator, providing organizations with learning audits, research benchmarking, workshops, and strategic guidance.

Brain Rules for Learning: Who Knew? We All Did. | Social Learning Blog

Dashe & Thomson

by Andrea on April 15, 2011 in Classroom Learning , Informal Learning , Training Development , blended learning , eLearning , social learning Recently, I was lucky enough to attend a keynote speech by Dr. John Medina on his book Brain Rules at the eLearning Guild’s Learning Solutions 2011 conference. What if we could customize training programs for each learner using adaptive software technology?

Brain 141

Unlocked Learning—Training analytics made easy

Coassemble

So our CEO Ryan started consulting with firms to see how knowledge was being shared effectively and where teams engaged most. One of the biggest eLearning mistakes that occur with online training is devoting disproportionate amounts of time to assessment. The earliest and most widely accepted and formalized training assessment process was the Kirkpatrick Model by Dr. Donald Kirkpatrick. Being able to measure your team’s training is crucial to its effectiveness.

Free learning & development webinars for August 2017

Limestone Learning

Investments in programs have generated mixed results. On the one hand the volume of programs is increasing; on the other hand, the business impact is less evident. Tuesday, August 8, 2017, 12PM – 1PM PST: Adjusting Your Consultative Selling Approach to Engage the Modern Buyer (Free for ATD members) Today’s buyers are ultra-informed and have more options than ever before. This preview focuses on the eLearning Strategies for Driving Business Results track. eLearning

Why Companies Should Spend More on Social Learning | Social.

Dashe & Thomson

technologies into our training programs, but rarely do we find a client that wants to create a robust learning environment comprised of both formal and informal components. Among industries, a greater number of technology companies and business services/consulting firms spent money on these tools. Leaders have to be willing to put some money behind training programs and they have to trust the statistics validating informal and social learning principles.

Social 154

The LTEM Training & Learning Evaluation Model

Convergence Training

And in particular, we talked about Kirkpatrick , Philips , Brinkerhoff , and Kaufman. And not only that, but our learning evaluation gurus, Kirkpatrick, Brinkerhoff, etc., Comparing LTEM and Kirkpatrick. Level three of Kirkpatrick is similar to tier seven, transfer.

48 Books Every Aspiring Chief Learning Officer Should Read

TalentLMS

As eLearning continues to become more and more ubiquitous, instructional designers and anyone designing online courses in the corporate world needs to read this book. Highly engaging and, dare I say it, fun to read, Telling Ain’t Training will change the way you approach planning your next training program. She has written and edited fifty books in her thirty plus years in training and consulting private organizations, government, and nonprofits. Kirkpatrick.

ELM Expert Series: 3 Fundamental Pillars to Sales Training Success

eLearningMind

Organizations are currently spending billions of dollars a year on sales training without seeing a lasting impact to their programs. By developing programs with a solid foundation, sales training can shift from being just a required organizational function to a strategic sales partner that provides direction and helps grow revenue. Instructional design uses analysis and instructional theory to ensure higher retention of information through intelligent program design.

Learning Objectives and Corporate Goals: How to create the perfect training

TalentLMS

The second misconception we are denouncing is the Kirkpatrick’s Evaluation process to determine the effectiveness of the training materials. While the primary goal of a training program is to increase individual knowledge, its ultimate goal is to raise competency levels in a task determined in the job profile of the learner. Define and prioritize the corporate mission and goals to determine which training program is most suitable and which has the most impact on performance.

Embracing Innovation in Learning | Social Learning Blog

Dashe & Thomson

This reminds me of a session I attended on emotional intelligence at the eLearning Guild ‘s Learning Solutions 2011 conference last month. Most recently, Ive been working on training programs for the propane industry.

Free L&D webinars for February 2019

Limestone Learning

Well, the world of learning and development is loving showing you some love, with a bouquet of free webinars on everything from instructional design to performance consulting , plus tons more. Wednesday, February 6, 2019, 12PM – 1PM PT : Comparing the elearning Titans: Adobe Captivate vs. Articulate Storyline vs. TechSmith Camtasia Welcome to the eLearning tool slug-fest. You’ll learn how to: Create a storyboard and convert it into an eLearning course.

Free L&D webinars for January 2018

Limestone Learning

Tuesday, January 9, 2018, 11AM – 12PM PT: Connecting Compliance to Business Strategy (Free for ATD members) Are your compliance training programs strategic and aligned to business, or simply an obligatory duty with a check-the-box mentality? You will learn: The risks presented by compliance programs based on a checkbox mentality. One reason lies in the hands of missing learning connectivity before, during and after programs. Maximize results from your training programs.

LearnX Asia Pacific 2009 - Day 1

E-Learning Provocateur

Bringing Generations Together through Collaboration and Informal Learning: Faith Legendre , Senior Global Consultant at Cisco WebEx , provided the audience with a synopsis of our 4 major generations today (Generation Vet, Boomers, Gen Y & Gen X), and an overview of their changing learning styles over time (push to pull, formal to informal, comprehensive to nibblets, and physical classes to online).

Free L&D webinars for May 2018

Limestone Learning

Tuesday, May 1, 2018, 11AM – 12PM PT: The ROI Dilemma: Measuring Results of Your Learning Programs (Free for ATD members) Significant resources are being allocated to training and development across most organizations, but many companies still find themselves unsure of results. Show you how to leverage Kirkpatrick’s model of assessment and create a targeted strategy around level three and four assessments. The top performance consulting skills organizations most desire.

Cammy Beans Learning Visions: Youre So Immature: e-Learning in Some Organizations

Learning Visions

Cammy Beans Learning Visions Musings on eLearning, instructional design and other training stuff. He was venting about Kirkpatrick evaluations. Are you a strategy consultant? Beachward Bound Crowdsourcing: Authoring Tools & LMS Questions My Summer ID Reading List ► June (3) eLearning Authoring Tools Mindmap The Two Faces of ePortfolios The Unofficial eLearning Salary Calculator ► May (9) Book Review: Ruth Clark’s Evidence-Based Training.

The Only Person Who Behaves Sensibly Is My Tailor

Charles Jennings

We measure how many people have attended a class or completed an eLearning module, or read a document or engaged in a job swap or in a coaching relationship. Attending a course or completing an eLearning module tells us little apart from the fact that some activity occurred. First, it does show small positive effects in the largest of workplaces, although diversity councils, diversity managers, and mentoring programs are significantly more effective.

Tips for Small L&D Departments: An Interview with Emily Wood

Convergence Training

Learning and development professionals, including elearning developers, have to wear many hats. But it’s even more true for L&D/eLearning professionals who work in small learning development departments. This article is an interview (in text and video format–scroll to the bottom for the video version) with Emily Wood, who is her own “elearning department of one” at a non-profit based in Portland, Oregon. eLearning Training

Free learning & development webinars for August 2020

Limestone Learning

Learning Consultant, walks you through the ins and outs of building professional interactions in just minutes using Storyline 360. If you’re in charge of training a sales team, you know how hard it is to justify any new investment in your program these days.

Free 53